| Home | Old Testament Studies | Ecclesiastes Table of Contents | Previous Section | Next Section |
ECCLESIASTES 1
PARAGRAPH DIVISIONS OF MODERN TRANSLATIONS*
NASB | NKJV | NRSV | TEV | NJB |
The Futility of All Endeavour | The Vanity of Life | Title and Thesis | Life is Useless | Prologue |
1:1-2 | 1:1-11 | 1:1-11 (1-11) |
1:1 | 1:1-8 |
(2) | (2) | |||
(3-8) | ||||
1:2-11 | 1:2-8 | |||
1:3-11 (3-11) |
||||
(9-11) | 1:9-11 | |||
The Futility of Wisdom | The Grief of Wisdom | The Search for Wisdom | The Philosopher's Experience (1:12-2:26) |
Life of Solomon (1:12-2:26) |
1:12-18 | 1:12-15 | 1:12-18 | 1:12-13a | 1:12-14 |
1:13b-15 | ||||
(15) | (15) | 1:15 (15) |
||
1:16-18 | 1:16-18 | 1:16-18 | ||
(16-17) | ||||
(18) | (18) |
* Although they are not inspired, paragraph divisions are the key to understanding and following the original author's intent. Each
modern translation has divided and summarized the paragraphs. Every paragraph has one central topic, truth, or thought. Each version encapsulates
that topic in its own distinct way. As you read the text, ask yourself which translation fits your understanding of the subject and verse divisions.
In every chapter we must read the Bible first and try to identify its subjects (paragraphs), then compare our understanding with the modern
versions. Only when we understand the original author's intent by following his logic and presentation can we truly understand the Bible. Only the
original author is inspired—readers have no right to change or modify the message. Bible readers do have the responsibility of applying
the inspired truth to their day and their lives.
Note that all technical terms and abbreviations are explained fully in the following SPECIAL TOPICS:
Hebrew Grammatical Terms and
Glossary.
READING CYCLE THREE (see "Bible Interpretation Seminar")
FOLLOWING THE ORIGINAL AUTHOR'S INTENT AT PARAGRAPH LEVEL
This is a study guide commentary, which means that you are responsible for your own interpretation of the Bible. Each of us must walk in the light we have. You, the Bible, and the Holy Spirit are priority in interpretation. You must not relinquish this to a commentator.
Read the chapter in one sitting. Identify the subjects (reading cycle #3). Compare your subject divisions with the five translations above. Paragraphing is not inspired, but it is the key to following the original author's intent, which is the heart of interpretation. Every paragraph has one and only one subject.
GENERAL BACKGROUND TO THE BOOK
WORD AND PHRASE STUDY
NASB (UPDATED) TEXT: ECCLESIASTES 1:1-2
1The words of the Preacher, the son of David, king in Jerusalem.
2"Vanity of vanities," says the Preacher,
"Vanity of vanities! All is vanity."
1:1 | |
NASB, NKJV, LXX | "The Preacher" |
NRSV, NET | "the Teacher" |
TEV | "the Philosopher" |
NJB | "Qoheleth" |
REB | "the Speaker" |
JPSOSA (footnote) | "the Assembler" |
Peshitta | "Kohlat" ("Preacher" in Lamsa's footnote) |
There is no DEFINITE ARTICLE here, although it does appear in Eccl. 7:27; 12:8. This is a function more than a title. The best translation would be "professor" or "teacher" (BDB 875, KB 1080). See Introduction, Name of the Book, C. and Authorship, F.
▣ "the son of David" This verse and verse 12 imply that this is speaking of Solomon, but other references throughout the book do not fit Solomon. I believe that an unknown wisdom teacher(s) used Solomon's wisdom, wealth, power, and position as a literary foil to critique life. See Introduction, Authorship, C.
1:2 "vanity of vanities" This is a Hebrew superlative (cf. Eccl. 1:2 and 12:8). The word means "vapor," "breath" (i.e., name of Adam and Eve's second child), or "mist" (BDB 210 I, KB 236 I, cf. James 4:14). Its emphasis is either
This is a key term and recurrent phrase in this book (i.e., used 38 times, cf. Eccl. 1:2,14; 2:1,11,15,17, 19,21,23,26; 3:19; 4:4,7,8,16; 5:7,10; 6:2,4,9,11,12; 7:6,15; 8:10,14; 9:9; 11:8,10; 12:8). Notice how it begins and ends the book! The term is used sparingly in other wisdom books; Job, 5 times; Psalms, 9 times; and Proverbs, 3 times.
For different theories about how it affects the strong statements in this book, see Introduction, Authorship, H. I prefer option #1.
This theological presupposition will be the lexical grid through which I interpret the book (i.e., this is what life without God would be like).
▣ "all is vanity" Notice the root, "vanity" (BDB 210 I, KB 236 I), is used five times in this one verse! The Handbook on Ecclesiastes by UBS, says the term should be understood as
Therefore, it communicates the reality that life is full of unanswerable questions (p. 4). The person knowledgeable in wisdom will know this, but will continue to trust God and keep His commandments (i.e., traditional conclusion of the book, chapter 12).
This refers to the uncertain and unpredictable activities of life. These are a result of fallen humanity trying to live life in his own strength, independent from God. This is the condition left by the Fall! See SPECIAL TOPIC: THE FALL OF MANKIND
The Hebrew term "all" (BDB 481, KB 474), often translated "everything," is a common word, but is used unusually often in Ecclesiastes (cf. Eccl. 9 times in chapter 1; 17 times in chapter 2; 13 times in chapter 3, etc.). Qoheleth uses this inclusive language to express his theological emphasis on
NASB (UPDATED) TEXT: ECCLESIASTES 1:3-11
3What advantage does man have in all his work
Which he does under the sun?
4A generation goes and a generation comes,
But the earth remains forever.
5Also, the sun rises and the sun sets;
And hastening to its place it rises there again.
6Blowing toward the south,
Then turning toward the north,
The wind continues swirling along;
And on its circular courses the wind returns.
7All the rivers flow into the sea,
Yet the sea is not full.
To the place where the rivers flow,
There they flow again.
8All things are wearisome;
Man is not able to tell it.
The eye is not satisfied with seeing,
Nor is the ear filled with hearing.
9That which has been is that which will be,
And that which has been done is that which will be done.
So there is nothing new under the sun.
10Is there anything of which one might say,
"See this, it is new"?
Already it has existed for ages
Which were before us.
11There is no remembrance of earlier things;
And also of the later things which will occur,
There will be for them no remembrance
Among those who will come later still.
1:3 "what advantage does man have in all his works" All human efforts, as well as all other human activities, are meaningless if there is no God (atheistic humanism, naturalism).
Oh my, what a terrible worldview!
NASB, LXX | "advantage" |
NKJV, NJB, REB, Peshitta | "profit" |
NRSV | "gain" |
TEV | "what do you have to show for it" |
JPSOA | "real value" |
This Hebrew root (BDB 452, KB 404) has several meanings:
The form here is found only in Ecclesiastes (cf. Eccl. 1:3; 2:11,13 [twice]; 3:9; 5:8,15; 7:12; 10:11; another form of the term is a substantive from the Qal PARTICIPLE, cf. Eccl. 6:11; 7:11,16; 12:9,12). It is obviously a key term because it describes the goal of mankind's search for meaning, purpose, and contentment!
NASB | "work" |
NKJV, REB, LXX, Peshitta | "labor" |
NRSV, NJB | "toil" |
JPSOA | "gains" |
NET | "effort" |
The VERB "work" (BDB 765, KB 845, Qal IMPERFECT), used twice, has several connotations. The root can mean
In this context #3 fits best, but one feels the presence of the other connotations in the root (there are several verses where the root is used twice, cf. Eccl. 1:3; 2:10,11,18,19, 20,21,22; 4:8; 5:18; 9:9).
1:3, 9, 13, 14 "under the sun" In my opinion this is a second key phrase (PREPOSITION, BDB 1065; DEFINITE ARTICLE and NOUN, BDB 1039) in interpreting the entire book. It is used twenty-five times and only in Ecclesiastes. It reflects mankind's futile efforts without God (i.e., "under the sun"; the parallel phrase, "under the heavens," is also used several times.).
Qoheleth examines physical life (by observation, i.e., natural revelation) and comes to the conclusion that it is vanity (cf. Dictionary of Biblical Imagery, p. 228).
1:4ff This begins a poetic stanza:
It is obvious that the genre and structure are not easy to identify and outline in this book.
1:4 The phrase "remains forever" is used in a relative sense (cf. Exod. 21:6).
This verse is expressing the fleetingness of conscious life (cf. Job 14:2; Ps. 90:5-6; 103:15-16; Isa. 40:6-7) versus the stability of the spiritual creation (as an aspect of YHWH's permanence, cf. Ps. 104:5; 119:90).
The Hebrew 'olam must be interpreted in light of a given literary context. It has a wide semantical field.
SPECIAL TOPIC: FOREVER ('olam)
1:5 Psalm 19:4-6 presents this same truth in great poetic majesty, but here the sun's daily task is seen as a vain, meaningless, wearisome repetition (i.e., the natural order and stability of physical creation of Gen. 8:22).
▣ "hastening" This term can mean "panting" (BDB 983 I, KB 1375, Qal ACTIVE PARTICIPLE), as in weariness or desire (i.e., Ps. 119:131). The sun grows weary hurrying every day to finish its course (cf. Ps. 19:4-6). This is the first in a series of eleven Qal ACTIVE PARTICIPLES reflecting nature (cf. Eccl. 1:5-7). The wind, like the sun, hurries to finish its repetitive course.
1:7 The Aramaic Targums and Rashi speculate the water returned through underground tunnels.
1:6 The Septuagint and Vulgate relate the first part of this verse to the sun, but in context it refers to the wind (a word play with "vanity") as another meaningless activity (as is the flowing of rivers to the sea, v. 7).
1:8 "All things are wearisome" Physical creation is in a repetitive, mysterious routine (i.e., Eccl. 1:9):
This premise is the author's first and primary presupposition about earthly existence (i.e., "there is nothing new or significant in an endless cycle of physical creation"). The principle is begun in Eccl. 1:8a and followed by three explanatory phrases:
These describe the generations that come and go (cf. Eccl. 1:4a). They all experience
NASB | "man is not able to tell it" |
NKJV | "man cannot express it" |
NRSV | "more than one can express" |
TEV | "a weariness too great for words" |
REB | "no one can describe them all" |
LXX | "a man will not be able to speak of them" |
Peshitta | "a man is not satisfied with utterance" |
JPSOA | "no man can ever state them" |
The author's list of meaningless repetition in nature could be multiplied endlessly. The implication is not only fallen human's inability to state clearly the meaninglessness and hopelessness brought about by the cycles of nature, but also the sense of purposelessness it brings to human existence!
Humans cannot tell because they do not know (i.e., apart from divine revelation). Human searching for answers is hopeless without divine revelation.
SPECIAL TOPIC: WAYS OF REVELATION
1:9 "That which has been is that which will be" This refers to meaningless repetition with no apparent purpose or attainable goal (this is sarcasm of human activity without God. Compare Isa. 55:6-13!). This describes humanistic atheism and, for that matter, eastern religious philosophy (i.e., wheel of karma).
▣ "there is nothing new under the sun" This repeated theme is one of two keys to interpreting the book. The author is showing the meaninglessness and hopelessness of life without God; without purpose; without eternity! The readers are forced to contemplate human existence, earthly life, if there is no God!
This is where the modern issue over origins takes on its sharpest focus.
These are the ultimate questions of human worth, dignity. Are we really made in the divine image (cf. Gen. 1:26-27) for fellowship with our Creator (cf. Gen. 3:8)?
1:10 "See this, it is new" "See" (BDB 906, KB 1157, Qal IMPERATIVE) is from a supposed objector (i.e., diatribe). He is answered by his faulty remembrance of history (cf. Eccl. 1:10- 11). The only constant is the empty repetition (both physical and existential).
1:11 | |
NASB | "earlier things" |
NKJV | "former things" |
NRSV | "people of long ago" |
TEV | "what happened in the past" |
NJB | "of the past" |
JPSOA | "the earlier ones" |
REB | "those who lived in the past" |
LXX | "the first things" |
Peshitta | "former generations" |
This MASCULINE PLURAL ADJECTIVE (BDB 911, KB 1168) refers to people, Lev. 26:45; Deut. 19; Ps. 79:8, while the FEMININE PLURAL refers to events, Isa. 41:22; 42:9; 43:9; 46:9; 48:3; and possibly Isa. 61:4. Therefore, the NRSV has the better translation.
This verse is characterized well by Robert Gordis, Koheleth, the Man and His World, a Study of Ecclesiastes, p. 208, as "This verse gives the reason for Eccl. 1:10. Things appear new only because the past is forgotten (Levy)—an additional element in the vanity of human existence; not only can nothing be accomplished, but the memory of the effort is wiped out (Hertz)."
NASB (UPDATED) TEXT: ECCLESIASTES 1:12-15
12I, the Preacher, have been king over Israel in Jerusalem. 13And
I set my mind to seek and explore by wisdom concerning all that has been done under heaven. It is a grievous task which God has
given to the sons of men to be afflicted with. 14I have seen all the works which have been done under the sun, and behold, all is vanity
and striving after wind. 15What is crooked cannot be straightened and what is lacking cannot be counted.
1:12 "the preacher" See note at Eccl. 1:1.
▣ "have been king" This is the first of several reasons why Solomon was not the author, but a literary foil (see Introduction, IV. Authorship, C).
The VERB "was" (BDB 224, KB 243, Qal PERFECT) is used often in the previous paragraph (Eccl. 1:9 [twice], Eccl. 1:10 [six times]). Time implications in Hebrew verbs must be determined from the context. The perfect tense implies a past condition, not a current one. Was there ever a time when Solomon was not king after once becoming king? The rabbis felt this problem and surmised that Solomon experienced a judgment similar to Nebuchadnezzar (cf. Daniel 4) and was removed from active leadership over Israel for a period of time (Targum on Eccl. 1:12; J. Sanhedrin 20c). This is just supposition and imagination trying to explain away the grammatical features of this text.
1:13 "mind" This is literally "heart," which is Hebrew imagery for the entire person.
▣ "seek" This word means "seek with application" (BDB 205, KB 233, Qal INFINITIVE CONSTRUCT, cf. Ps. 111:2; 119:45).
▣ "explore" This word means "to investigate" or "to go to the root of a matter" (BDB 1064, KB 1707, Qal INFINITIVE CONSTRUCT, cf. Eccl. 7:25). It was used often of exploring the land of Canaan in Numbers 13, but here it refers to a search for truth (cf. Prov. 2:4).
▣ "wisdom" There are two words used in Wisdom Literature that related to knowing. A good example is Prov. 1:7:
They form a complementary pair. One focuses on practical living and the other on academic knowledge. They are both needed to live life well. They should not be contrasted, but both be sought after (cf. Job 28:28; Ps. 111:10; Prov. 9:10; 15:33).
▣ "concerning all that has been done under heaven" See note at Eccl. 1:3. This is a key concept, crucial for a proper interpretation of the book. It is parallel to the phrase "under the sun."
▣ "God" This is the Hebrew name Elohim. It is used for God as Creator, Provider, and Sustainer of all life on this planet. This is the only name used for Deity in the book.
SPECIAL TOPIC: NAMES FOR DEITY, C.
NASB | "a grievous task" |
NKJV | "this grievous task" |
NRSV, JPSOA | "an unhappy business" |
TEV | "a miserable fate" |
NJB | "what a wearisome task" |
LXX | "a worthless task" |
Peshitta | "a difficult task" |
NET | "a burdensome task" |
The word "task" (BDB 775, KB 857) is used several times in the book (cf. Eccl. 2:26; 3:10; 4:8; 5:13; 8:16). God has given humans, made in His image (i.e., Gen. 1:26-27), a desire to know and understand their place and purpose in creation, but sin has destroyed our ability to find the answer.
The ADJECTIVE (BDB 948, KB 1250-1256) basically means "evil" or "bad." It is used several times in the book (cf. Eccl. 1:13; 2:17; 4:3,8; 5:1,14; 6:2; 8:3,5,9,11,12; 9:2,3 [twice],12; 10:13; 12:14) to describe life!
God has given humans who are made in His image an insatiable desire to know, to understand, but it cannot be satisfied in this fallen world. The tree of the knowledge of good and evil was a disaster, not a blessing! We know evil and ignorance, but not God or ultimate questions. Life is a mystery!
Notice the definition from NIDOTTE, vol. 3, p. 452.
"Qohelet's evaluation of human concerns or tasks is negative; they are an evil or misfortune (rā; Eccl. 1:13) perpetrated against the human race, causing frustration and pain (2:23) and of no advantage whatever (2:11). This state of affairs exists not because of human moral failure or want of skillful exercise of human industry, but because the Creator has irrevocably determined and arranged it so (1:13; 3:10-11; cf. 1:15). Qohelet's theology of creation is in striking contrast and tension with the profoundly affirmative theology of creation reflected in the Pentateuchal creation accounts of the creation hymns in the Psalms (→ br' I, create, separate, # 1343). Qoheleth's theology of creation is also in tension with the early Christian theology of the apostle Paul, who situates the creation-human order within the soteriological framework of primordial human sin and subsequent curse/futility destined for eschatological reversal (Rom. 8:20-21). Qohelet, in contrast to Israel's traditional wisdom assumptions, postulates an enigmatic, frustrating created order. For him, the latter reflects the character of a labyrinthine deity, inimical to the triumphalist human quest for a secure and meaningful mastery of existence. On the problem of correlating this aspect of Qohelet's thought with the positive affirmations present in the final form of the book, see M. Fox. Qohelet and His Contradictions, 1990 (→ Ecclesiastes: Theology)."
1:14 "under the sun" See note at Eccl. 1:3. Notice the number of times this phrase or a parallel phrase is used (cf. Eccl. 1:3,9,13,14; 2:11,17,18,19,20,22; 3:16; 4:1,3,7,15; 5:13,18; 6:1,5,12; 7:11; 8:15 [twice],17; 9:3,9 [twice],11,13; 10:5). This is one of two key theological phrases to understanding the book (see Introduction III. B.)!
▣ "all is vanity and striving after wind" This is another repeated phrase (and parallel) which characterizes this book (cf. Eccl. 1:2,14; 2:1,11,15,17,19,21,23,26; 3:19; 4:4,6,8,16; 5:7,16; 6:2,4,9,11; 7:6,15; 8:10,14[twice]; 9:9; 11:8,10; 12:8). See word study at Eccl. 1:17. It characterizes human's search for meaning, happiness, and purpose without God.
1:15 "crooked. . .straightened" The words "crooked" (BDB 736, KB 804) and "straight" (BDB 1075, KB 1784, Qal INFINITIVE CONSTRUCT) are often used in moral senses. This phrase is found only in Ecclesiastes (Eccl. 1:15; 7:13; 12:9). They form the basis for the Hebrew concepts of righteousness and sin (see Special Topic below). This may have been an oft quoted proverb (i.e., NIV, cf. Eccl. 7:13)..
Not only can fallen mankind (even covenant humanity) not "know" or "find," but they cannot "fix." Life is a mystery and it cannot be understood or changed by those walking through it. In historical context, this may be a slap at divination or simply a realistic statement of mankind's inability to correct the human condition (but God can, cf. Eccl. 7:13; Job 12:14; Isa. 14:27). Wisdom knows that some things cannot be changed and goes on with life, but it also knows some things can be changed by godly living and godly choices. The problem is knowing which is which!
NASB (UPDATED) TEXT: ECCLESIASTES 1:16-18
16I said to myself, "Behold, I have magnified and increased wisdom more than all
who were over Jerusalem before me; and my mind has observed a wealth of wisdom and knowledge." 17And I set my mind to know
wisdom and to know madness and folly; I realized that this also is striving after wind. 18Because in much wisdom there is much grief,
and increasing knowledge results in increasing pain.
1:16 "I said to myself" This statement reflects the ego problem in the human search for wisdom and happiness. The essence of the Fall (i.e., Genesis 3) was "self-centered independence from God." This characterizes our fallen world. A life turned inward toward "me," "mine" can never find God's wisdom and God's peace (even a Davidic king)!
SPECIAL TOPIC: THE FALL OF MANKIND
▣ "I have magnified and increased wisdom" This is a claim to be wiser than all the Jewish leaders in Jerusalem before him (cf. 1 Kgs. 3:12; 4:29-34).
1:16; 2:7,12 "more than all who were over Jerusalem" This is another example of how Solomon will not historically fit as author. Only David preceded him. See Introduction, Authorship, C.
NASB, NRSV, REB | "I applied my mind" |
NKJV | "I set my heart" |
TEV | "I was determined" |
NJB | "I have applied myself" |
JPSOA | "I set my mind" |
LXX, Peshitta | "I perceived" |
This theme of sincere, dedicated, aggressive human effort (cf. Eccl. 1:13,17; 8:9,16) is not enough to find wisdom or purpose in an ever-changing, yet always the same, physical creation.
▣ "to know" This VERB (BDB 393, KB 390) is used three times in this context (two are Qal INFINITIVE CONSTRUCTS and one is a Qal PERFECT VERB).
SPECIAL TOPIC: KNOW (using mostly Deuteronomy as a paradigm)
▣ "wisdom. . .madness and folly" These contrasting pairs:
show the futility of mankind's search for ultimate answers about the mysteries of human existence (cf. Eccl. 2:12). Biblical faith is not a human search, but a divine revelation. God wants His special creatures to know Him, but without faith and revelation, it is impossible (i.e., "striving after the wind")!
NASB | "striving after the wind" |
NKJV | "grasping for the wind" |
NRSV, NJB | "chasing after wind" |
TEV, REB | "chasing the wind" |
LXX | "waywardness of spirit" |
Peshitta | "vexation of spirit" |
This CONSTRUCT (BDB 946 [KB 1265 II] and 924) can mean:
From Eccl. 1:14 it is obvious that "vanity" (BDB 210 I) and "wind" (BDB 924) are in a synonymous/parallelism.
SPECIAL TOPIC: BREATH, WIND, SPIRIT
1:18 "in much wisdom there is much grief" This, like Eccl. 1:15, may have been a well known cultural proverb from the sages. The search for meaning and happiness cannot be accomplished without God (cf. Eccl. 2:23; 12:12; Prov. 1:1-7; 1 Cor. 13:2). As a matter of fact, it becomes maddening!
The more you know, the more you know you do not know!
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
This is a study guide commentary, which means that you are responsible for your own interpretation of the Bible. Each of us must walk in the light we have. You, the Bible, and the Holy Spirit are priority in interpretation. You must not relinquish this to a commentator.
These discussion questions are provided to help you think through the major issues of this section of the book. They are meant to be thought-provoking, not definitive.
| Home | Old Testament Studies | Ecclesiastes Table of Contents | Previous Section | Next Section |
Copyright © 2014 Bible Lessons International